“Life is pain, Highness.”
If you were a child of the 80s like me (and especially of the microgeneration called the Xennials), you might recognize that line from The Princess Bride. With this line, a disaffected farmboy-turned-pirate succinctly tells the princess he loves that to expect a life free of suffering is to deny the complexities of the human condition.
As an existential therapist, I help people deal with the fact that pain is inevitable. (And please note, I’m not speaking here about chronic, debilitating states of distress that call for therapy or medication, but about the everyday struggles that we all face at one point or another.) The inherent meaninglessness of being alive naturally produces despair. The weight of responsibility we hold for our own actions can cause anxiety and depression. But these very experiences drive us to shape ourselves and find meaning.
Existential therapy calls on us to engage with these difficult realities in service of improving our overall state in a way not many other psychological interventions do.
For instance, positive psychology would have us perform a type of emotional bypass by insistently focusing on how to not suffer. CBT offers a cognitive bypass by telling us to think different thoughts. Mindfulness would train us to observe and release, observe and release, until we detach from our pain. And those practices have their place—often, they help us get through the day.
From the existential perspective, though, the deeper work is not to stop suffering, but to make meaning of it. When we do battle with our pain, we counterproductively entrench and amplify those thoughts and feelings. But when we learn what pain has to teach and choose how we carry it, we expand around it to create space for other qualities: acceptance, hope, joy.
So rather than feeding your pain more energy, try something new. Turn toward it, rather than pushing it away. Seek to understand it, rather than insisting it is wrong.
Here are some examples.
Depression as self-protection
What is depression? A downward turn of feelings, a shutdown or shutoff of aliveness. Noticing when this shift occurs can reveal that it might be your system protecting you.
This numbness can be a balm to the sharp sting of neglect, disappointment, or loss. It may be that the dark fog of depression is what’s helping you get through when your life would be otherwise unbearable.
People sometimes become depressed after a major life change, bad or good. Change, even when we choose it, is overwhelming. Depression can turn off that overwhelm and give our systems time to adjust. And when our circumstances are traumatic, the shutdown of physical and emotional activity is a way to conserve energy in order to survive and get through.
Depression is adaptive when it helps us cope in these ways. The pain of your depression may be a necessary distraction from the greater pain of something else. Knowing what’s happening might not change the shutdown, but it might just increase your compassion for yourself instead of compounding your misery.
Anxiety as a mobilizing force
If depression turns down the dial on aliveness, anxiety cranks it up. Anxiety can be a “too much” experience: too much physical sensation, too much to think about, too intense of a feeling.
Yet it also helps us pursue what we want or escape what we don’t. When something needs to change, whether that’s getting out the door to work on time or leaving an unhealthy relationship, anxiety is there to motivate you.
Anxiety tells you what needs attention and what doesn’t, helping you focus on what matters most in the moment. And sometimes what we call “anxiety” can also be also understood as anticipation or excitement.
So when you’re anxious, something in your environment may be calling for action. Being curious about that feeling can help you find out what that is and give it the needed energy. It can also help stop the spiral of ever-worsening anxiety that feeds on itself.
Anger as care for self
Sometimes anger masks sadness or fear, in which case we call it a secondary emotion. In these instances we need to look under the anger to feel what’s at the core.
Other times, though, anger is the primary emotion. And your anger might be a form of self-love.
Anger at the doctor who just ignored your symptoms says “I deserve care.” Anger at the friend who blew you off, again, says “I am worthy of reciprocal relationships.” Anger at yourself, when you do something you regret, says “I care about living my values.”
Anger calls on us to attend to our boundaries, either upholding the ones we have or putting new ones in place. It asks us to respect our own worth and to engage with others who do the same. Your anger wants you to know that you matter.
Am I proposing you go around being angry at people? Of course not. But I am asking you to not be afraid or dismissive of your anger, and instead listen to its wisdom.
How to befriend your pain
So how can you turn toward the painful emotions that you’d rather not feel at all? Depression overwhelms, anxiety paralyzes, anger consumes. The good news is that, to shift your relationship to your suffering, all you need to do is ask a question.
The next time you’re struggling, just notice the pain you’re feeling and ask, “How are you trying to help me?” In this practice, we’re taking a page from Internal Family Systems therapy, which is all about interacting with ourselves in ways that ease suffering.
Asking this question creates a little space between you and the pain—less intensity gives you more room to interact with it. Answering it provides insight into the deeper problems your pain is trying to help you solve.
In the moment, this practice can decrease self-directed judgment, criticism, or pity, and nudge you toward more internal kindness and understanding. While your suffering may not disappear, you will no longer be increasing it by struggling against it.
Over time, dialoguing with your painful feelings in this way can shift your whole framework. As you become more aware of the core needs your coping strategies developed to meet, you will find ways to exercise more choice in how you try to meet those needs.
Suffering is part of life. But you can hold yourself, and your suffering, with more care as you persist through it.